N
News Celebrities Life

Haunting photos of kids' bikes at Oklahoma murder site where 5 teens including Ivy Webster & Brittany Brewer found dead

Author

Christopher Harper

Published Sep 10, 2026

GUT-WRENCHING photos from the scene where seven bodies were found on Monday show kids' bicycles lying abandoned on the rural property.

A day after the horrific discovery on the farmland of convicted sex offender Jesse McFadden in Henryetta, Oklahoma, the eerie scene painted a bleak picture of the lives of the victims killed in the tragedy.

The farmhouse where the bodies of seven people were found on Monday

12

The farmhouse where the bodies of seven people were found on MondayCredit: Steve Dennett for The US Sun
The property sat uninhabited just a day after the grim find and bright blue bikes could be seen stacked next to the home

12

The property sat uninhabited just a day after the grim find and bright blue bikes could be seen stacked next to the homeCredit: Steve Dennett for The US Sun
Mourners were pictured leaving red heart balloons on the gate surrounding the property

12

Mourners were pictured leaving red heart balloons on the gate surrounding the propertyCredit: Steve Dennett for The US Sun
Two dogs that seemed to be uncared for sat on the front porch of the modest home

12

Two dogs that seemed to be uncared for sat on the front porch of the modest homeCredit: Steve Dennett for The US Sun

Several feet from the entry gate sat an uninhabited, modest brown and white-colored one-floor home.

The only sign of life encompassing the house were two dogs sitting on the front porch, who barked away at mourners visiting the property to pay their respects.

A woman and a child were seen placing three red-hearted balloons on the noble panels and gates surrounding the property.

Stationed on the left side of the home sat a set of aqua-colored children's bikes stacked on one another.

Read more in The U.S. Sun

The grim discovery came on Monday afternoon as the Okmulgee County Sheriff's Office searched for missing teens Ivy Webster, 14, and Brittany Brewer, 16, after they failed to contact their parents over the weekend.

Brittany's parents said their daughter was staying over at the McFadden family's home but she knew something was wrong when the 16-year-old didn't call for their usual Saturday chat.

"I knew something was wrong cause she wasn’t answering my—I mean, I tried to call," mom Malaina Schabell told NewsNation.

At McFadden's farmhouse, authorities found the bodies of seven victims, including that of the convicted sex offender and Ivy and Brittany.

Most read in The US Sun

Four additional bodies, including McFadden's wife, Holly Guess, 35, and her three kids, Rylee Elizabeth Allen, 17; Michael James Mayo, 15, and Tiffany Dore Guess, 13, were also found.

It was revealed in a news conference on Wednesday that all of the victims were found outside the residence but detectives believe the remains could have been staged after their deaths, local Fox affiliate KOKI-TV reported.

Okmulgee Police Chief Joe Prentice said that each victim was shot one to three times and they appeared to have been running from the shooter at the time of their deaths.

Investigators also noted that McFadden suffered self-inflicted gunshot wounds.

Brittany's father, Nathan Brewer, said his daughter had stayed with the McFadden family before without issue and that he was unaware of the suspect's criminal past.

DARK PAST

McFadden spent 17 years behind bars for sexually assaulting Krystle Strong when she was just 16 years old in 2003.

Krystle, now 36, recounted the horrific abuse she experienced at the hands of McFadden after making the unpleasant four-hour drive from Kansas to the crime scene in Henryetta on Tuesday.

She spent an hour at the remote farmhouse and was shocked that there wasn't a single police cruiser on the scene.

"I only came to the site because one of the [local] reporters asked me to do a live there, but all that did was make me nauseous," Krystle exclusively told The U.S. Sun, saying she traveled to Oklahoma to pay respects and see victim Ivy's mom, whom she spoke to via Facebook.

As she stood on the property, drones flew over the ravine where some of the bodies were found and Krystle admitted that the scene made her "psychically sick."

“It’s too hard to talk about, and no, I won’t be back to the crime scene," she said.

Authorities called off an Amber Alert for the two missing teens after they executed a search warrant on McFadden's property on Monday afternoon.

The horrific discovery was made the day McFadden was set to appear in court for allegedly soliciting child pornography from a teen with a contraband cell phone while in prison.

Two of the teen victims were visiting the McFadden home for a sleepover at the time of the murders, family said

12

Two of the teen victims were visiting the McFadden home for a sleepover at the time of the murders, family saidCredit: Steve Dennett for The US Sun
Holly Guess' kids, from left to right, Tiffany Guess, Michael Mayo and Rylee Elizabeth Allen

12

Holly Guess' kids, from left to right, Tiffany Guess, Michael Mayo and Rylee Elizabeth AllenCredit: AP
Ivy's family was 'shocked' when they learned about Jesse McFadden's criminal history

12

Ivy's family was 'shocked' when they learned about Jesse McFadden's criminal historyCredit: Facebook/Shannon Boykin
Brittany Brewer's father, Nathan, said that his daughter was selected to represent the small town of Henryetta in an upcoming beauty pageant

12

Brittany Brewer's father, Nathan, said that his daughter was selected to represent the small town of Henryetta in an upcoming beauty pageantCredit: Facebook/Brittany Brewer

'A PREDATOR'

When Krystle caught wind of the news, she says it brought back gut-wrenching memories of when McFadden brutally attacked her in 2003, which led her to contact Ivy's mom Ashley.

Krystle fought back tears during an exclusive interview with The U.S. Sun outside the farmhouse where the murders occurred on Holly Road in Henryetta.

"I started digging on Facebook and spoke to Ashley [Ivy's mom]. I felt sick. I then heard people were dead. I had to pull over to throw up [...] I couldn't even drive," she said.

"I was going to Walmart at that point getting groceries, I saw someone had posted on Facebook. I was like: 'We don’t need to be saying stuff that’s not true.'

"Then, I found out it was. I was so sick and sobbed for about 25 minutes."

Recalling her ordeal with McFadden, she said the pair hung out in the early 2000s as he was dating a friend of hers.

"He would make fun of me, he was just gross," she recalled. "He was a weird personality, not somebody I would date, never. 

“I was at a keg party in McAlester [40 miles north of the crime scene].

“I was seeing a guy and got a little tipsy, he drove me home, and I left my truck in McAlester, he stayed with me for a little bit and then ended up going home.

"About 3 o’clock in the morning, I heard a beating on the door, I was like: ‘Who the hell is this?’ They kept knocking and knocking.

“I was at my dad’s, he was away. I had shorts and a tank top on, and I opened the door. I was like: ‘Jesse, what are you doing here?’"

He told her his girlfriend had kicked him out and demanded to be invited in, and when Krystle told him to go home, he forced his way inside the property.

BRUTAL ATTACK

Within minutes he launched himself at Krystle, who says she begged her attacker to get off her and asked him what he was doing.

"He was shoving a sock in my mouth, and next thing, I was being dragged through the living room, tied to my futon with one of my dad’s bungee cords," she said. "It was very traumatic." 

"When he was on top of me, he pulled out a knife, he stuck it to my throat and kept pushing harder and harder, saying: ‘If you don’t shut up, I swear to God, I’ll kill you right here.’

"I was like: ‘Look, Jesse, we’re homies, we go way back. If you just quit and get off me, I won’t tell anyone, it’s our secret.'"

"When the ordeal was ongoing, it was brutal, and it was just like my soul left my body."

Krystle says she tried to placate him and promised that if he untied her, she would help cover up for him.

He demanded she take a shower and destroy her clothing, which the shaken teen agreed to do as he paced up and down in her home.

"He asked me to go and wash the clothes or get rid of them," she stated.

"There were two doors on the trailer at the time. I said: ‘I got you.’ And while he was pacing about, I bolted, I ran a quarter mile naked to the neighbor's house."

After she sobbed to her neighbor, the police were called, and she said they found him by a local river bleeding out after slitting his wrists.

“That's why I had a gut feeling today he would have taken his own life," she told The U.S. Sun as she looked across the property after his victim's bodies had been removed from the home.

McFadden was sentenced to 20 years behind bars for the attack on Krystle but served 17 and was released in 2020.

The registered sex offender was facing further child pornography charges for allegedly swapping images of another teen with a smuggled phone in prison in 2016.

Krystle said she begged the DA not to release him after seeing the story on the news, but he managed to secure his release later and bagged himself a job.

He married Guess some months ago but knew his court date was coming up for the child pornography case.

"Why was he not on parole? I told the police he was a predator," Krystle said. "They should have done more."

Krystle said she lived in fear after McFadden was released from jail and fears he may have committed other crimes since he got out.

"He was still able to get out for all of this to then happen. It blows my mind. 

"In the past three years, I wonder what else he may have done. It's Jesse, look what he did to me and to these poor babies.  

“I have been looking over my shoulder every day, especially at night and when I’m in my car. 

"He was a coward."

“I wanted to come here and pay my respects to Ashley. I wanted to hug her and tell her it was OK. I have babies that age.

“I was told after I was raped I may never have kids, but I was then blessed with four children."

She added that the ordeal was devastating, and she will do everything she can to support the families and other rape victims in the aftermath of the tragedy.

Read More on The US Sun

A motive for McFadden's killings has yet to be determined but the police chief said in the Wednesday press conference that "normal people" can't understand it.

"Normal people can't understand why. People who perpetrate crimes like this are evil. Normal folks like us can't understand it," he said.

The property where the bodies were found is down a dirt road with no other homes nearby

12

The property where the bodies were found is down a dirt road with no other homes nearbyCredit: Steve Dennett for The US Sun
Krystle Strong, who was 16 years old when she was sexually assaulted by Jesse McFadden in 2003, came to the property this week after hearing the shocking news

12

Krystle Strong, who was 16 years old when she was sexually assaulted by Jesse McFadden in 2003, came to the property this week after hearing the shocking newsCredit: Steve Dennett for The US Sun
Holly Guess' mother said her daughter and her teenage grandchildren were 'manipulated and controlled' by McFadden

12

Holly Guess' mother said her daughter and her teenage grandchildren were 'manipulated and controlled' by McFaddenCredit: Facebook/Holly McFadden
Ashleigh Webster shows a photo of Ivy Webster and Tiffany Guess at her home in Henryetta

12

Ashleigh Webster shows a photo of Ivy Webster and Tiffany Guess at her home in HenryettaCredit: AP